There’s a new debate cruising through the biking paths — are E-Bikes “cheating,” or are they a smart way for older adults to stay active? As a personal trainer in her 60s, I’ve gone the classic route with my trusty beach cruiser. My husband, at 65, just switched to an E-Bike and swears he’s getting a better workout than ever.
So, who’s right? Let’s take a ride through the facts.
Manual Bikes: The Classic Calorie Burner
Pros:
- Full-body effort: You’re powering every push of the pedal, which means more cardiovascular and muscular engagement.
- Burns more calories (potentially): A longer, harder ride can increase energy expenditure.
- Simple, budget-friendly: No battery or motor, just you and the road.
Cons:
- Hills and headwinds can be tough: For those with joint issues or lower fitness levels, this can be discouraging.
- Shorter distances: You might cut your ride short if you’re tired, missing out on extended cardio benefits.
E-Bikes: Assisted, but Still a Workout
Despite the motor assist, E-Bikes aren’t lazy riding. In fact, a 2018 pilot study published in the Clinical Journal of Sport Medicine found that older adults who used E-Bikes improved their cardiovascular fitness and covered longer distances compared to manual bike riders, with comparable exercise benefits.
Additionally, a University of Colorado Boulder study showed that adults riding E-Bikes for 40 minutes three times a week improved aerobic capacity and blood sugar control within a month.
Pros:
- Longer rides, more often: The assist makes it easier to ride uphill, into the wind, or simply farther than you might on a manual bike.
- Joint-friendly: Great for knees, hips, and those recovering from injuries.
- Confidence booster: If you’re nervous about your stamina, the assist is like a reassuring hand on your back.
Cons:
- Less muscle load: You might not engage your legs and core as intensely as with a manual ride.
- Pricey: Quality E-Bikes aren’t cheap, and they do need charging and maintenance.
- Can feel bulky: Heavier than a regular bike, especially if the battery dies mid-ride!
So Which Is Better?
Here’s the truth: the “better” workout is the one you’ll actually do consistently.
If you love powering your own ride like I do — go manual! You’ll build strength and endurance every time you saddle up. But if you’re like my husband and find joy in going longer distances, tackling hills with a smile, and riding more days each week — then E-Bikes are a fantastic fitness tool.
Let’s Stay Connected!
As a personal trainer and coach for over 30 years, I share videos and posts specific to the importance of aging well through proper fitness and nutrition on my Instagram page. I look forward to having you as a follower.
Thanks for stopping by my Blog. Remember to subscribe and never miss a free update.